Toastmasters' speech contests and radiosport contest operations. Behind the scenes of both
activities is a judging system, the specifics based on the structure and layout of each contest event.
I've written about contest judging before ([CLICK HERE]) altho it was rather brief.
One thing common to BOTH forms of competition is:
"DECISIONS of the JUDGES is FINAL"
Whether we like it or not, the bottom-line is the bottom-line.
Here are a few examples:
- In a recent California QSO Party radiosport, the San Diego Contest club (running
as NX6T) took 2nd place in the Multi-OP category to a single-OP station who admitted
he ran solo and yet submitted a Multi-OP log. Had he not said anything his 1st-place would've been uncontested. However, when he admitted being a Single-OP, members
of our team filed a grievance with the CQP contest committee. They eventually award
him the 1st-place and suggested that next year would be different. - Several years ago, the Amateur Radio Club of Alameda (ARCA) running as K6QLF thought we had a slam-dunk 1st-place win for Alameda County until W6TCP also submitted a log for Alameda County. Their station was on the hills overlooking the bay area; however, I thought the actual station location might just be over the county line
in Contra Costa County and filed a grievance. The powers that be did their geographical research and said their hilltop location was in fact, in Alameda County. - In a recent Toastmasters Division-level speech contest, it was clear that my speech delivery clearly won the audience over way beyond any of the other contestants.
([CLICK HERE] to see the video). However, from the point-system used for scoring speech contests, my delivery technically made a number of errors which got me marked down pointwise giving my presentation a 2nd-place. - Years ago, for the Islands on the Air (IOTA) contest, I attempted to persuade the RSGB contest committee that Alameda qualified as an island - 100 years ago it was called Alameda Island. Unfortunately, in 100 years' time, all manner of geopolitical changes
can occur to an area, changing its [island] status. Near Alameda is of course Alcatraz
and Angel Islands. - Then again, it can sometimes work in our favor. In recent years I have been competing in the QRP classifications during such GiGs as the CQP, NAQP and Sweepstakes. Posting my score to the 3830Scores website often listed me in 2nd-place. Then when the contest results are released, WQ6X ends up taking a 1st-place. Either my competitors posted a fictitious score on 3830, or the Log Checking facility dinged enough of their contacts to significantly reduce their score below the WQ6X submission.
If I dig back far enough, over a dozen similar kinds of occurrences can be found.
That would only serve to make me right about how I had been wronged. Those events
are LONG GONE. The real lesson(s) to be learned in all this is for us to do the best we can
during each contest event. Radiosport and Toastmaster speech contests are highly ethically run.
No matter what my "monkey mind" may have to say about things, the way it turned out is the way
it turned out.
Will I do it all again next year?
YOU KNOW I WILL!


.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)


